A shocking American Idol results show sent Siobhan Magnus packing. Magnus, who was one of the top weekly performers, was voted off after it came down to her and Casey James. American Idol fans will be shocked to find out what happened last night and who got voted off American Idol.
A shocking bottom three of Michael Lynche, Siobhan Magnus and Casey James wowed the studio audience. Now American Idol is down to the top five after Magnus received the least amount of votes. Who are the American Idol top five? Casey James, Michael Lynche, Crystal Bowersox, Lee Dewyze and Aaron Kelly round out the top five American Idol contestants.
Did Siobhan Magnus deserve to go home? Who else could have been voted off American Idol?
Siobhan certainly wasn’t in the Crystal Bowersox perception range and probably couldn’t have competed for the overall title if she didn’t make the final five. Magnus though might have one of the better opportunities from the show to have a successful pop career. Her incredible talent was showcased weekly and her ability to hit high notes was often annoying to the judges but still very impressive to the audience. She is unique and very memorable. Siobhan, who was nearly tearing up after getting voted off American Idol, still performed with the poise of a super star. She has star quality written all over her.
Who should have been voted off on American Idol in my opinion? I kind of felt this was the last week for Aaron Kelly. He’s young and quite popular but he doesn’t quite stack up to the remaining five in terms of overall developed talent. Aaron Kelly is impressive considering his age but he still needs to grow a bit. I also thought Michael Lynche could have been going home. I was shocked that Casey James was in the bottom three of the American Idol results show after his Shania Twain rendition the night before. It was an absolute American Idol shocker that Casey was in the bottom three and Aaron Kelly wasn’t.
With that said, who do I think will win the coveted American Idol title? I still think it’s Crystal Bowersox’s game to win. Unless she stumbles way harder than this week, I think Crystal has it wrapped up. I like Lee and Casey and believe both will make very good recording artists. I find it hard to believe that either will surpass the popularity of Crystal at this point in the game. But you never know with American Idol. That’s why each week the American Idol results show is completely unpredictable. That’s why viewers who miss the American Idol results show will be in for a shocker when they find out who was voted off last night! The answer, unfortunately this week, is Siobhan Magnus.